An NYC paramedic and firefighter who gave up on love! Decided to give online dating a chance back in 2015. Samantha was a single mom with two precious daughters that stole James’ heart! Four years later they built a strong foundation of love and they are ready to spend the rest of their lives all together as one.
On April 13th 2019 James told Samantha to dress up, they were going to a graduation celebration dinner. Little did Samantha know James would be proposing and surprising her with her family and precious daughters! She entered a lighted rooftop facing the Empire State Building which is one of her favorite places in all of NYC! Samantha is obsessed with red roses and candles and nothing could’ve made the night more complete than by adding those extra details in. With a beautiful red marry me sign shinning away, down James went and got on one knee. The love of their children and family surrounded them and they embraced this huge moment. It was a dream come true. Two heroes that live for saving others found love that saved them!
Ok, we all heard that Valentine’s Day proposals might be tricky. On the one hand it could be very romantic and sweet, on the other hand it might be too obvious and little cliche. Yes, all girls are expecting a ring on the Valentine’s day, so if you still want to do it at least make it really special and extraordinary. The most important thing is to take her off guard, to propose when she least expect it or doesn’t expect at all. So, how can we do that? Here are our top 5 marriage proposal ideas for Valentine’s Day in NYC.
1 – She expects a date, so make a perfect date
Get a table at that amazing restaurant that she was talking about for months. Take her to the movie or a music show after and before taking her home, propose. The point here is that she will enjoy the date and even if she expects a ring, she will forget about it by the end of the day. And you will definitely take her off guard by proposing by her door.
It goes without saying that all reservations should be made in advance as its a very busy day and you don’t want to be scrambling last minute. Same goes with the proposal planner and venues, if you know you want to make that grand proposal on Valentine’s Day in NYC, you need to make all the arrangements months in advance.
Want to make it more romantic? Hire a personal chef and make a restaurant right at your place. Decorate the room with flowers and candles and enjoy the meal. It will definitely be a huge surprise for her and more intimate atmosphere for both of you. Our room makeover package and secret proposal photographer will be perfect combo for this.
We all know that Valentine’s Day is one of the best days for the local businesses to make profit. Don’t get to that trap. You know that that horse carriage ride doesn’t cost $700 per ride, and that bar doesn’t charge $35 for the frozen heart mix drink. There are plenty of places to go and lots of things to do outside those common clichés.
We would recommend going with the private venue as there will be lots of people everywhere and most of the places will be overpriced. Pick a private rooftop or an indoor penthouse and decorate it the way you want it. You can invite all her close friends and family and share the moment with them. Make it personal and memorable. Dont forget to hire a secret photographer and videographer to capture that big surprise.
The biggest tourist trap is believing that love has to be loud and public. But in reality, what she really wants is a private, intimate moment shared with close people —especially on a busy day like Valentine’s Day.
The best way to surprise your significant one is to propose when she least expects it. Plan a date in advance, give her the restaurant address and make it look like nothing else is going on. Once you arrived to the restaurant, the table will be ready and everything will looks like a normal restaurant date, until one by one, people at nearby tables stand up and start singing. In a minute, the entire restaurant is singing a serenade and you propose. Her surprise is guaranteed. Our skilled photographer will be there to capture that grand surprise.
Or you can tell her that you hired a photographer to take a pictures of you two, which is a perfect gift on Valentine’s Day.
Get to the park or walk around the city with your photographer, pose, kiss and have fun. She might suspect that you want to propose, so hold on till the end. At the last frame you pop the question. It will take her by surprise, again because she wouldn’t suspect it coming.
If you still want to do it on Valentine’s day and want to avoid all the romantic clichés, we would say do something extraordinary! Make it big and spectacular. Propose on the Times Square Big Screens. No one ever expects to see a love declaration on a big screen in Times Square, she will be shocked to see it. Just keep in mind, that the spots are going fast so you need to book it in advance.
Want something less public, but still grand and spectacular? Rent a private rooftop with the Empire State Building view, add sparkles, huge Marry Me letters, a photographer and a drone video. Big surprise guaranteed!
Mercer Labs digital screen proposal is a perfect way to surprise your partner on Valentine’s Day. Just imagine walking around the museum exploring the art as one of the screens changes to a personal message and you proposes. She’ll never see it coming.
Another digital proposal option would be a personal message on the Times Square Billboard. We can arrange a screen, that would show your personal message every hour for 1 minute during the day. Its a fun way to propose in New York.
Proposing on Valentine’s Day can be tricky, but with the right planning team it can be the most unforgettable marriage proposal experience in New York.
Here are the most common questions couples ask when planning a Valentine’s Day proposal:
1. Is Valentine’s Day a good day to propose?
Yes, it is a good day for a romantic proposal. Want to avoid the crowds, propose a day before or after the Valentine’s day.
2. Should I propose in public or private on Valentine’s Day?
Many people assume a big public proposal is the dream—but most partners prefer a private, intimate moment. So plan a private proposal.
3. How far in advance should I plan a Valentine’s Day proposal?
As early as possible. Popular venues, rooftops, restaurants, and photographers book out weeks (sometimes months) in advance for February 14.
4. Do I need reservations even if I’m not proposing at a restaurant?
Yes. Restaurants, rooftops, hotels, and experiences fill up fast on Valentine’s Day. Last-minute planning usually limits your options and would costs twice more.
5. What are the best proposal ideas for Valentine’s Day in NYC?
Private rooftops, styled room makeovers, unique spaces like immersive art rooms, and intimate setups with skyline views are top choices.
6. How do I keep the proposal a surprise?
Make it look like a normal date. Give her a restaurant address or casual plan so nothing feels “big” is coming. The more normal it looks, the bigger the surprise.
7. Is Valentine’s Day too cliché to propose?
It can feel cliché if it’s generic. It doesn’t feel cliché if the setup is personal, thoughtful, and tailored to her personality.
8. What time of day is best to propose on Valentine’s Day?
Morning or late-night proposals can feel more private and less crowded.
9. Should I hire a photographer for the proposal?
Absolutely!
10. What if the weather is bad?
Always have a backup plan. Indoor options (private rooms, hotel setups, immersive spaces) are perfect safety nets for February weather.
Immersive marriage proposal ideas in New York
Allow professionals to take care of your proposal in New York
New York City, with its iconic skyline and rich cultural landscape, offers countless ways to propose. For those seeking a truly unforgettable and immersive experience—something beyond the traditional dinner or park setting—the city presents a range of innovative and visually stunning options that engage the senses and create lasting memories. A perfect blend of technology, art, emotion and creativity – for a modern couples who want something personal, unique, and futuristic:
Mercer Labs: Museum of Art and Technology
For couples, who appreciate modern art and want a true “wow” moment, this museum proposal offers a bold, dreamlike experience that turns imagination into reality. Just picture this, the whole room turning into your personal dream with surreal projections, personal message and striking music. It is a perfect way to surprise your partner with the marriage proposal of her dreams. Proposal at the Mercer Labs is ideal for artistic couples and those who appreciate modern technologies and visual effects.
For those who desire a fully custom experience, interactive projection mapping can turn any space into a personal narrative. By projecting visuals, messages, or animations onto a wall or structure—accompanied by synchronized audio—proposers can craft a story that leads naturally to the moment of asking. Just imagine stepping getting into a room with her favorite cherry blossoms and custom decor, it looks like a dream and she cant believe you created all that.
Proposing in the heart of Times Square offers a grand, public gesture with global resonance. By renting a digital billboard and displaying a personalized message, you can transform a busy city intersection into a deeply personal moment. This type of proposal is not for the shy couples, as Times Square is one of the busiest areas in the city. But this type of proposal will definitely have a ‘ wow’ factor.
For a more intimate experience, schedule the proposal late at night or early in the morning, both times would have less crowds and more photo opportunities.
An immersive proposal is more than a spectacle—it is an opportunity to create an emotionally resonant memory through space, sound, and storytelling. In New York City, the possibilities are as vast as the skyline. Whether one chooses to propose through digital projections, interactive art, or a cinematic surprise, what matters most is that the moment reflects the uniqueness of the relationship it celebrates.
For assistance in planning and capturing your immersive proposal in NYC, feel free to reach out for tailored recommendations and professional photography services.
Tatiana Caicedo
How to Propose in Private in New York City?
Allow professionals to take care of your proposal in New York
In New York City, a bustling metropolis with some 8.2 million people, privacy is a hot commodity—especially privacy for a proposal. But don’t give up hope yet! We have several destinations across the Big Apple where you can ask the big question in peace and quiet.
Interested? This guide will cover all the details of planning an unforgettable proposal in private in New York City. Read on to find out where and how to find that “yes” moment!
Choose Where to Propose
Picking the right place to pop the question will make your proposal memorable for all the right reasons. Since solitude is the goal here, you’ll have to choose your venue carefully to provide a more intimate experience.
Central Park Gazebo: Believe it or not, you can plan a private proposal in one of New York City’s most iconic outdoor spots. Rent out this stunning gazebo, including decorations, to create a stunningly romantic moment straight out of a fairy tale. Our secret photographer will be there to capture the big moment.
Movie Theater: Your love story deserves to be seen on the big screen, and what better way than renting out a movie theater? You and your partner can reminisce on fond memories and look forward to the next chapter with a personalized movie trailer screened just for you two.
Modern Midtown Rooftop: This is an excellent choice for those who hope to propose in private in the Big Apple. The fresh air, string lights, and the Empire State Building towering nearby all make this a gorgeous destination for a proposal. There is nothing like a private rooftop proposal in New York.
2. Arrange Decor and Recording
Though our proposal packages include decorations and a photographer, you may want to consider other add-ons. A colorful rose petal aisle or a floral arch will make your proposal all the more romantic, while video recording or extra guests can also be arranged.
No matter what you have in mind, you should decide these details well in advance to ensure the big moment goes off without a hitch.
3. Get Your Partner to the Proposal
Now that you’ve decided when, where, and how you’re going to propose, you need to find a way to get your partner to the proposal. Though convincing him or her to join you in Central Park or on a rooftop in Midtown Manhattan might seem difficult, this part is all about strategy.
Consider what the “backstory” might be here, giving your partner a realistic reason that you want them to head to your private proposal spot. The better your story, the more pleasantly surprised your significant other and the more memorable your proposal.
4. Have a Backup Plan in Place
Rain isn’t exactly unusual in New York City, so you should have a backup plan if you plan on proposing outdoors. A few clouds shouldn’t overshadow your big day! Though you can change your proposal location, you may be better off embracing Mother Nature’s mood swings.
A rainy evening can be a deeply romantic setting—after all, some of the most famous love stories, from “Pride and Prejudice” to “The Notebook,” feature rainy scenes. Come prepared with umbrellas, or work with our dedicated proposal planner to explore your options. We also have a lots of venues with the indoor locations, that might work perfectly for a rainy day.
We hope our guide has given you some ideas as to how you can propose in private in New York City. The Big Apple has all kinds of settings and locations to suit your love story, so make sure to book one of our private spaces soon for a truly magical start to your marriage.
Tatiana Caicedo
Rainy Day marriage proposal in Brooklyn
Allow professionals to take care of your proposal in New York
One of the most frequently asked questions we receive is, “What if it starts raining on my proposal day?” Since marriage proposals are typically a surprise, we understand the difficulty of changing the date and rearranging all the plans.
Therefore, our best advice is to either proceed with the proposal as planned or book a location with both indoor and outdoor areas to avoid any weather-related issues. Venues with indoor and outdoor options may be more expensive, but they offer peace of mind. The weather in New York can be unpredictable, making it difficult to predict the conditions on your chosen day.
How can you ensure your proposal is perfect, even on a rainy day?
First of, embrace the rain and make it romantic. Instead of focusing on how bad it is, think of how romantic it will be to share a kiss under the umbrella with the raindrops reflecting the lights. Some of the most beautiful and emotional proposals happen in the rain. A skilled photographer can capture stunning, cinematic shots, making your rainy-day proposal look even more magical. Just be sure to bring clear umbrellas for stylish, rain-proof photos, and embrace the moment rather than stress about the weather.
With the indoor/outdoor venue options, you can propose inside and then step out on the terrace to take romantic pictures with the umbrella.
Secondly, make sure your post-proposal plans are set. If rain is in the forecast, secure a dinner reservation and arrange transportation in advance. Once the rain starts, finding a car or a great table at a restaurant can be challenging, and walking between locations in bad weather can dampen the celebratory mood. Planning ahead ensures a smooth and enjoyable experience after the big “YES!”
Focus on what you can control.
This might sounds easy, but from experience, people are too focused on the weather and how ‘it should be’ that they are not focusing on the moment itself. Focus on what you can control—the experience, the emotion, and the love behind the moment. Think of this as a unique part of your love story that you will remember forever.
How to choose a right venue?
We’re all about NYC skyline views, so we always recommend choosing a venue with both an indoor space and an outdoor terrace to enjoy the best of both worlds. The beauty of a private venue is that it offers more than just a stunning backdrop—it gives you complete control over your special moment. You can invite close friends and family, decorate the space exactly how you envision it, play your favorite music, and take photos comfortably without strangers watching.
Yes, you can propose at a hotel bar or a public observation deck, but the experience won’t be the same. A private venue ensures intimacy, exclusivity, and a stress-free atmosphere, allowing you to focus on the moment without distractions. Plus, with unpredictable NYC weather, having an indoor-outdoor setup guarantees that your proposal will be perfect, no matter what.
A little rain won’t stop a beautiful proposal—it might even make it more unforgettable. Whether you embrace the romance of a rainy-day moment or opt for a venue with indoor options, the most important thing is the love and excitement of the day.
If you’re feeling unsure about how to plan a weather-proof proposal, we’re here to help! Our team specializes in crafting seamless, stress-free proposals, ensuring that everything goes perfectly—rain or shine.
Tatiana
ROOFTOP PROPOSAL
Allow professionals to take care of your proposal in New York
The sun is out and the time has begun for rooftop cocktails, pool parties and rooftop restaurants. Proposing on a New York rooftop is something that neither you nor your partner will forget. To see the whole city skyline and share that moment with your partner is really precious and we know how to make it unforgettable for both of you.
Rooftop marriage proposals in New York don’t have to break the bank. There are many public rooftop options, from old favorites like the Empire State Building and Top of the Rock to the remarkable One World Observatory, the Edge or the Summit. All of them have exceptional views of the Manhattan skyline. The main “cons” of these locations are lack of privacy, long waiting lines and no options for customizations. But our skilled photographer would guarantee you the iconic skyline shot.
If you want somewhere away from the crowds and entry lines, we have a catalog of beautiful rooftop proposal ideas to make your proposal the perfect fit for you both. Our private rooftop proposals in New York City will take your partner’s breath away.
Unlike public venues where your plans are left somewhat to the hands of fate, when you book a private rooftop you have more freedom. We can decorate your rented rooftop and hire a musician to play your song of choice.
Proposing in public might be uncomfortable so we always prefer private setting for a special moment. Just imagine the elegant setting with the personalized decor and only close people. What a perfect way to start a new chapter! And our photo and video team will make sure that you remember this moment forever.
We work with NYC’s most exclusive rooftops and penthouses, each with panoramic views. Most of our rooftop options are in the Midtown area with views of the Empire State Building. We also work with Downtown area, Brooklyn, and even Long Island City, offering spectacular views of the city.
Here are our most popular rooftop proposal packages:
1. Empire State view rooftop
One of our most favorite isthe Empire State view rooftop, that is located right in the heart of Midtown area. This rooftop has a direct view of the Empire State Building and looks like a place from the movie scenes. We love setting up a ” Heart Arch” or “Marry Me” sign here, as it works perfectly with the rooftop ambiance.
Brooklyn private rooftop is an excellent choice for those who are looking for a unique way to propose, this rooftop is overlooking the Manhattan Bridge and has skyline views of the city. This location is perfect for a rainy day proposal as it has an inside room and a huge outdoor terrace. Our 3 ft “Marry Me” letters look really good in this setting.
In the package Manhattan rooftop marriage proposal, you can see excellent city view roof with an amazing skyline view and decorations. This rooftop is perfect for daytime or brunch time proposals, but the best time to propose here is sunset. This unique location has almost 360-degree views, so you can see the sky and the whole city changing colors. Our secret proposal photographer will insure you get all the best shots from this proposal.
Looking to ‘wow ‘your partner? The Midtown view terrace would do that for you. This breathtaking location has the most broad views of the Midtown skyline area and is ideal for the most elegant proposal in New York. Add a white heart arch or gigantic “Marry Me”letters to the package, and you will get the marriage proposal she always dreamed of.
For those who are looking for luxury and extravagant proposal in New York, we would recommend our Sparkling Rooftop in Midtown area. This rooftop has a direct view of the Empire State Building and has romantic fairy lights hanging on the top. Add two cold sparkles and spell out “Will You Marry Me” with the gigantic led letters and she wont believe her eyes.
The last but not least is Classic Empire State Building view terrace. This roof has a beautiful architectural structure and its overlooking the whole city and the Empire State Building. This will be a perfect for the late afternoon proposal, when all the lights are on and you can enjoy the serenity of the city. This location also has an inside room where you can hide from the rain or snow.
A stunning modern rooftop terrace overlooking the Empire State Building is all you need for a perfect ” Yes” . Imagine telling your partner that you are going to a new speakeasy bar, to secretly bringing her to a private rooftop, which is set just for you two. Conveniently located right in the Harold Square, this roof was designed for big surprises.
Conveniently located right on the 5th avenue and two blocks from the iconic building, this penthouse is an ideal venue for a custom proposal. Expansive floor-to-ceiling windows frame the skyline beautifully, while the private outdoor terrace offers flexibility for both indoor and outdoor setup options, ideal for creating a truly unforgettable moment. Add a flower arch and cold sparkles for a bigger surprise. Our secret photographer will be there to capture the big surprise.
Proposal 007 was founded by NYC residents. We know our city’s best kept secrets, and that includes the best rooftops as well. We offer outstanding service and full support on the day of your proposal, as well as photography and video options. We know precisely how to stage your proposal to get the best photographs of your day; a day that will remain with you forever.
